Year 2020: A topsy-turvy year

---

For many, the year 2020 was not good as the entire year was mainly affected by the pandemic Coronavirus (COVID-19), which started in Wuhan city of China at the end of 2019 but spread over the entire world at the start of the New Year. In the initial months, Iran and Italy were the two major countries, which were worst hit by the pandemic COVID-19 after China. These affected countries, however, were controlled soon with the imposition of strict lockdowns.  

Soon, the virus spread over to the USA, Australia, New Zealand and Africa as a forest fire. Pakistan received the virus through Pakistani pilgrims who returned from Iran and Saudi Arabia. The first patient who tested COVID-19 positive had come from Iran.

Pakistan has to impose a lockdown in March, which continued till August, but it was not so strict as people did not completely observe the Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs). The working class especially daily wage earners were the worst-hit section. Although the federal government had announced a one-time cash grant of PKR 12,000 to support the poor from the economic shocks of lockdown, this support could not reach to the majority of the population as the Prime Minister himself admitted that the government did not have data of 80 per cent workers.

The government also failed to impose SOPs due to a lack of cooperation from the masses. Media reported skirmishes between people and police, especially when police restricted people from going to mosques to offer Friday prayers.  

The virus’ intensity declined in July, but it suddenly increased again by the end of October and more people tested positive and the average number of deaths due to the virus increased manifold. This intensity of the disease still prevails on the last day of the year 2020. New norms of working from home, wearing masks most of the time and social distancing have now become part of our daily lives. We also worked from home till August when the government lifted the lockdown.

The year made a big impact on my personal life as I lost my mother on June 26. She suffered a stroke attack on 24^th June but could not survive and breathed her last within two days in the hospital. It was a big setback for my entire family. My father had already left the world in 2006.

Our family also witnessed some happy moments as well on the occasion of the wedding ceremony of my nephew Mairajuddin who got married on 12^th December.

The year 2020 would always remain in our memory with a lot of changes in the world’s politics. It was also the US elections year, in which Joe Biden won the election and in February he would become President of the world’s only superpower.

Politically, in Pakistan the opposition parties formed the Pakistan Democratic Movement (PDM), a grand alliance to topple PM Imran Khan’s government, which according to them has failed to deliver as the economy is in shambles and prices of essential items have skyrocketed. A series of public rallies were held across the country despite strict COVID warnings by the government.

The government stuck to its anti-opposition stance and many politicians were put behind the bars by National Accountability Bureau, which it has never proven. Nawaz Sharif had to leave the country to get his medical treatment in the UK, but he refused to return due to the government’s policies. He was already convicted of his corruption and was behind the bars.

Pakistani economy continued to suffer amid COVID-19-related lockdowns when common people suffered a lot. People witnessed a steep rise in prices of all essential goods when sugar and wheat prices went higher due to scandals in these two commodities, involving powerful personalities of the ruling political party. The government failed to provide any relief to the people and it continued its anti-public decisions like increases in petroleum, gas and electricity prices. It seemed the government machinery was not concerned with the common people’s problems.

With the dawn of the sun of the New Year 2021, it is hoped that situation would be improved in Pakistan and in the entire world.

Happy New Year!

Happy New Year!

Mafias run Pakistani economy: Dr. Kaiser Bengali

According to Dr. Kaiser Bengali, an eminent economist Pakistani economy is mostly run by mafias, who often join politics and the government to get “legal benefits.”

These mafias enjoy monopoly profits, which they use to further strengthen their political designs.

Dr. Bengali, who remained Advisor to the past governments in Sindh, Balochistan and Centre, while speaking at an online post-budget 2020-21 webinar on Sunday said sugar, wheat flour, fertilizer and paper industries are minting money by availing various subsidies and incentives in the form of tax exemptions. Most of the owners of these industries are either in the government or they are relatives of the ministers.

“You have heard about the sugar scandal and a good thing has happened that an inquiry report has been made public, which exposed how the sugar mafia is looting the national wealth by adopting all “legal procedures.”

Describing further, Dr. Bengali said the sugar mafia provides wrong figures and manipulates the situation for their benefit. First, they export sugar and claim subsidies on exports then create a shortage in the country to raise its prices. These sugar mill owners are mostly politicians, who often make policies for their benefit. Sugar mills are not paying properly costs to sugarcane growers and swindle taxes like FED and GST through manipulation.

Flour mills receive wheat from the government’s procured stocks at subsidised rates. The main aim of this incentive is that they would supply flour at lower rates. In fact, these mills purchase wheat from the open market and then sell flour at higher by mixing the rates. “They put the subsidy on wheat in their pockets and sell flour at higher rates,” he said.

In Pakistan, three paper mills have created a cartel, which has made many publishing houses bankrupt as they sell paper at higher rates. “Now the situation is such that most of the curricular books, even in Urdu are published and imported directly from China and Indonesia as there is no import duty on published books. The paper mafia is so powerful that every year the government announces to change the duty structure, but it always fails to do so.

He said most of the fertilizer manufacturing units are owned by the Military subsidiaries in Pakistan, which receive Sui (natural) gas at very cheaper rates, almost free, and also receive subsidies on the selling of fertilizer to growers.

It is a matter of fact that more than 60 per cent of fertilizer is being used by Punjab, whereas Sindh consumes only 20 per cent. The Sui gas-producing province Balochistan consumes only 4 per cent of the fertilizer, thus most of the subsidy goes to Punjab at the cost of smaller provinces like Balochistan and Sindh that produce the natural gas.

“We have not seen the reverse transfer of the benefit from Punjab to Balochistan,” he said adding that Punjab does not provide any subsidy to Balochistan while supplying wheat the people of Balochistan have to purchase wheat at the market rates.

Watch the entire speech: Click here

Unabated use of religion against opponents in Sindh

Sindh has witnessed two recent incidents in which the religious tool of blasphemy law was (mis)used against the opponents.

In the first case, the state on Tuesday filed a blasphemy case against a professor of Shah Abdul Latif University Khairpur Sajid Soomro with charges of contempt of Islam as he reportedly took part in the funeral of a Sindhi writer Atta Mohammad Bhanbhro. Prof. Soomro was later arrested by Khairpur police from his home early on Wednesday.

Prof. Sajid Soomro is also a famous writer and a member of Sindhi Abadi Sangat.

Another incident took place in Hyderabad where Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam (JUI) Fazlur Rehman group started a social media campaign against a leader of Women Action Forum (WAF) Dr. Arfana Mallah alleging that she has done blasphemy by condemning the Blasphemy law. Interestingly this law has been condemned by many, but why JUI-F found it objectionable in the case of Dr. Mallah.

The JUI-F’s local leadership asked the party workers through a Facebook post to gather at a mosque in Bhitai Nagar and from there they will proceed to a police station to lodge an FIR against the women rights activists Prof. Dr. Mallah who is teaching at the University of Sindh, Jamshoro.

Dr. Mallah had played a key role in organising the Aurat March at Sukkur in March this year despite severe opposition by fanatics and religious leaders including provincial leadership of JUI-F. Before the March, the JUI Sindh had threatened to stop the march.

Later, Women Action Forum issued a press release condemning threats to Dr. Arfana Mallah. “We demand that police thwart such nefarious attempts and that this situation is handled in a timely and lawful manner before any damage is caused,” the WAF statement added.

Interestingly both the victims are professors of universities. According to the FIR against Prof. Soomro, the police have included Section 295-A of the Pakistan Penal Code, which pertains to deliberate and malicious acts intended to outrage the religious feelings of any class by insulting its religion or religious beliefs.

Misuse of the Blasphemy law is quite common in Pakistan as this law, was made stringent by the Military dictator General Ziaul Haq and was misused against the opposition and minority activists. The law has hit vulnerable sections, especially women and minorities. In Sindh last year a couple of serious incidents happened in which people from the Hindu community were made targets.

I don’t know what is the main cause of concern for JUI-F leadership in Sindh this time against Dr. Mallah, but it is a matter of the fact that the religious zealots have always used this law as a tool to gain their nefarious designs.

According to a post by Azam Jahangiri of JUI F on Facebook, Dr. Arfana Mallah uttered derogatory words against the Blasphemy law in her Facebook post while condemning the registration of a case against Prof. Soomro. Therefore, his party under the leadership of Taj Mohammad Nahiyon is determined to lodge a blasphemy case against Dr. Mallah.

International Mother Language Day

The United Nations (UN) has declared 21st February as International International Mother Language Day to promote awareness of linguistic and cultural diversity and to promote multilingualism.

The United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) was first announced on 17 November 1999, which was formally recognized by the United Nations General Assembly with the adoption of the UN Resolution No. 56/262 Multilingualism in 2002.

The idea to observe International Mother Language Day was an initiative of Bangladesh as 21st February is the anniversary of the day when Bangladeshis fought for recognition of the Bangla language. There is a public holiday on 21st February in Bangladesh.

In 1948, the then Government of Pakistan declared Urdu to be the sole national language of Pakistan even though Bengali or Bangla was spoken by the majority of people combining East Pakistan (now Bangladesh). East Pakistan’s Bengali-speaking people protested. At that, time the majority of the population was Bengali speaking so they demanded Bangla be at least one of the national languages, in addition to Urdu.

The demand was raised first by Dhirendranath Datta, a member from East Pakistan on 23 February 1948, in the constituent Assembly of Pakistan. To demolish the protest, the government of Pakistan outlawed public meetings and rallies. The students of the University of Dhaka, with the support of the general public, arranged massive rallies and meetings. On 21 February 1952, police opened fire on rallies. Salam, Barkat, Rafiq, Jabbar and Shafiur died, with hundreds of others injured. This is a rare incident in history, where people sacrificed their lives for their mother tongue.

In Pakistan, the day is being observed with enthusiasm for the last few years as at two times the legislators from smaller provinces (Sindh, Balochistan and KP) have submitted two separate bills in the Parliament (National Assembly and Senate) to declare other languages of Pakistan as National Languages.

Even the Senate’s Standing Committee on Law and Justice passed “The Constitution (Amendment) Bill, 2016” on March 9, 2018, seeking the status of national languages for major provincial languages, including Punjabi, Sindhi, Pashto and Balochi.

But on both occasions, the proposed bills were rejected on the basis of majority as Punjabi-speaking people are in dominant in the Parliament.

Most of the information for this blog is taken from Wikipedia

Families Demand Students be Repatriated from China

A large number of parents and relatives of Pakistani students studying in China staged a protest demonstration outside Karachi Press Club demanding the repatriation of all the students from Wuhan city of China, where they are kept inside their rooms or homes due to the viral epidemic Novel Coronavirus (COVID-19).

Many countries including neighbouring India have airlifted their students from China, but Pakistan has refused to repatriate its citizens as according to authorities Chinese government is taking care of the Pakistani students very well.

“Wapas Lao Wapas Law, Hamare Bache Wapas Lao (bring back our children)” chanted the protesting relatives.

Carrying banners and placards, a large number of males and females, children and a wheel-chaired woman were demanding Prime Minister Imran Khan, Army Chief and politicians including Bilawal Bhutto Zardari to bring back their loved ones who are stranded in Wuhan city, where over 1500 people have died of viral infection and thousands are under treatment as Pakistan government had decided to keep them in China due to non-availability of effective quarantine and healthcare facilities at home.

According to reports, there were a total of 1300 Pakistani students enrolled in 25 universities of Wuhan before the outbreak of the Coronavirus epidemic but due to vacations about 500 students had already left the city but 800 were still stranded.

“We just want to see our children back in Pakistan as we don’t demand the government to make arrangements for their air tickets,” said a male speaker adding “we only want our children to be given permission to come back from Wuhan,” he added.

A woman said their children were kept in jail-like conditions in their homes and they were facing strict surveillance and restrictions despite the fact none of them is infected by the disease.

Some elderly women were weeping and said they felt helpless as the government has left the Pakistani student at the mercy of the Chinese and no politician or media is raising their voices for bringing back Pakistani students.

A man contacted a girl student living in China on his small phone and showed the girl’s face (which was covered with a mask) and said she was trying to tell their ordeal.

After some time of the protest, the protesters disperse peacefully.

Martyred Queen of Sindhis!

She was not a traditional queen, but still, she is called “Queen of Sindh”, even after her assassination, Sindhi people still call Benazir Bhutto as “Shaheed Rani” or martyred queen in love and respect. They have not forgotten her even after the passage of 12 years and people still remember her with wet eyes.

Another popular slogan famous in Sindh was: “ Zindah hai Bhutto Zindah Hai” (Bhutto is still alive), which started after the execution of former Prime Minister Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto. This is the main reason that despite high-level pre- and post-election engineering by the notorious “establishment” in every election, Sindhis always give vote for Pakistan People’s Party.

The PPP has been making governments in Sindh province after three consecutive elections since 2008. Even though many major political parties including Pakistan Muslim League Nawaz (PML-N) and Pakistan Tahrik-e-Insaf (PTI) (the current ruling party) have been contesting from Sindh, Sindhis have always preferred PPP in the love of its past leaders. It is the main reason that Asif Ali Zardari, the spouse of Benazir Bhutto has publicly announced the name change of his only son Bilawal as Bilawal Bhutto Zardari.

It is also a matter of the fact that there is no alternative political party in Sindh province, which can appeal to Sindhi voters, despite a record corruption and non-spending of budgets on the development of the backward areas of the province. Many PPP leaders are facing corruption charges in NAB and other anti-graft courts.

A Bloody Year

The 2007 year was full of events, which are still very clear in my mind. There was a lot of political upheaval in Pakistan, after a long military dictatorship of General Pervaiz Musharraf since the 12^th October 1999 military coup d’état. Military dictatorship was first challenged by then Chief Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry when the dictator and his other Generals asked Chaudhry to resign and he refused. The lawyers of the country announced support for Justice Chaudhry and launched the famous lawyers’ movement, which ultimately resulted in the restoration of the judiciary in 2008 and overall democracy in the country.

In the meantime, former Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto announced to return to the country despite a reported deal under the so-called National Reconciliation Ordinance (NRO) pact with the dictator General Pervaiz Musharraf, as she had said to be promised not to come back to contest the General Elections announced by the government in early 2008.

On her return to Karachi on 18^th October 2007, a deadly bomb blast occurred near Karsaz at her procession caravan heading towards Mazar of Quaid-e- Azam resulted in the deaths of over 170 workers of the Pakistan People’s Party, however, Benazir remained unhurt. After the incident, Benazir Bhutto blamed the government for the attack and named three close aides of General Pervaiz Musharraf including his cabinet minister Brig (Retd.) Aijaz Shah, a former head of the spy agency ISI Major General (Retd.) Hameed Gul and Chaudhry Pervaiz Ellah, a former Chief Minister of Punjab province and central leader of the pro-Musharraf Pakistan Muslim League (Quaid-e-Azam).

The following events in 2007 were more tragic and deadly as Benazir Bhutto was assassinated in a shooting and bomb blast incident in Rawalpindi just after she was coming back from an election rally at Liaqat Bagh on the 27^th of December. Elections were to be held on 8th January 2008 but were postponed till 18^th February after her assassination.

The entire country was engulfed in fire as protesting people set ablaze vehicles on roads in the cities and highways and burnt railway bogies at the main tracks. Pakistan railway reportedly suffered a loss of over Rs. 6 billion as 35 locomotives, 139 coaches and 65 stations were burnt, 36 bridges and 27 manned level crossings were damaged, signal and communication systems and tracks besides six tracks machines and cranes in the Karachi and Sukkur divisions of the railways were uprooted, suspending all kinds of rail traffic to and from the Sindh capital for five days. (Reference: daily Dawn, 28 Dec 2008)

Although Benazir Bhutto’s murder case in an Anti-Terrorism Court (ATC) has been decided in which all five arrested accused belonging to Tahrik-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) have been exonerated by the trial court and only a couple of police officers have been sentenced to jail terms, who are restored to their jobs after getting bail. The main petition against the Military dictator is still pending at Islamabad High Court and there is no hope for any punishment for the main killers.

After the 2008 elections, PPP succeeds to form a coalition government with support from PML-N, MQM and JUI-F. PPP and PML-N led government forced the dictator General (Retd.) Pervaiz Musharraf to resign from the office of President on a threat of impeachment. PPP Co-Chairman Asif Ali Zardari was elected President.

The PML-N withdrew its support to the PPP government on insistence to restore the judges as the PPP-led government of Prime Minister Yousuf Raza Gilani refused to succumb to their demands. PML-N remained in the opposition for the remaining tenure, even though the PPP government had restored the judiciary.

Unfortunately, 5-year government at the PPP was not able to arrest the killers of Benazir Bhutto even though the government got an investigation done by the UN investigators. Even the Sindh government has not succeeded in nabbing the responsible for the October 18, 2007 bomb blast at Karsaz, despite the fact it is in the power since 2008.

Aftermath riots in Karachi

I still recall that saddest eventful evening when I saw a ticker on the TV screen that Benazir Bhutto was seriously injured in a bomb blast in Rawalpindi. I was about to leave my office in the Clifton area at 5.30 pm on 27^th December 2007 and within a few minutes, another ticker flashed on the screen which stated Benazir is dead. It was really a great shock for everyone in Pakistan.

At that time I used do a part-time job in Daily Times as a sub-editor at its Business desk in the evening. The newspaper’s office was located at I. I. Chundrigar road near MCB’stallest building and my routine route were to go from Clifton via Mai Kolachithen Keamari flyover and Tower.

But on that day I could not reach the Keamari flyover as the entire traffic from the Tower side was coming back on both tracks of the Molvi Tamizuddin Khan (Queen’s) road and a car driver told me that people from Lyari have come out on the roads and closed down the bridge.

I took a U-turn and tried to take the route via PIDC and Shaheen Complex. The roads were full of traffic and eventually, I reached Dawn’s office, but it was almost impossible to enter into I. I. Chundrigar road as the entire thoroughfare was full of cars coming from the tower area, and even a single lane was not available to enter Chundrigar road.

After a wait the traffic started slowly as one track of the road was opened. It was just for passing a car, but even that was disturbed by the motorcycles that were trying to use that single lane with intervals. That one and half kilometre distance were covered in almost half an hour. But entering the building was a gigantic task. I succeeded in taking a U-turn from New Chali and fortunately found a space for a car inside the building. Earlier, it was almost impossible to find a space for a car inside the building, but I was lucky to find one on that day.

I came home at 1.00 am at night but there were horrible scenes on the road. At least two cars and a bank were burnt in my area in Khadda Market (DHA phase-5 Stadium Commercial). For the next three days, the entire market area was closed down and there was a curfew-like situation. There was a shortage of food items in many areas and at last, Rangers were deployed in the markets and the shopkeepers opened their markets.

Uncontrollable price hike

Prime Minister Imran Khan at his party’s meeting in Islamabad on November 15 termed the current spell of the price- hike in the country as “artificial” and a “conspiracy” against his government. The economists, however, believe that it is not a conspiracy against any government but , in fact, a mismanagement and bad governance on part of the government machinery especially at the provincial and local governments’ levels that have miserably failed to maintain control over prices.

They have also argued that the present price hike is mainly because of rise in inflation rate because of a number of economic factors: substantial increase in the prices of the utilities like gas and electricity, petroleum products, reduction in agriculture production and devaluation of Pakistan rupee, which caused increase in rates of imported products. Government’s increased borrowings from banks and international lenders because of the low tax recovery and increase in interest rates are other some economic reasons for rising inflation, said a senior economist Dr. Shahid Hasan Siddiqui, Chairman of Research Institute of Islamic Banking and Finance.

He said the hoarders and mafias also play their role in increase in prices of commodities and products. They have official machinery’s support. Increase in sugar and wheat prices are some examples, he added. Indirect taxes have also increased, which has affected the middle and poor classes negatively, said Dr. Siddiqui.

The provincial food departments in both Sindh and Punjab have failed to control smooth supply and demand of the essential commodities like wheat and flour. Flour millers in Sindh have been complaining that the commodity traders are hoarding the wheat to manipulate the prices. Moreover the provincial government’s food department did not procure wheat in Sindh this year on the pretext that the government godowns were full due to last year’s storage. This has resulted in exponentially increase in price of a 100 kg bag of wheat in November against in April, when new wheat crop arrived in the market.

Flour millers say this year wheat crop was not short but due to corruption, mismanagement and inefficiency in the provincial governments the prices have increased and are still rising. This year the government had also allowed export of wheat, which was later banned in September but a lot of the new crop’s products were already sold out abroad. According to the statistics of Department of Plant Protection under the Ministry of National Food Security and Research Pakistan exporters send around 17655 tons of wheat between the period from August 1, 2018 to August 25, 2019.

The millers said when the government had realized that earlier estimates of the supply were not correct it should have allowed wheat imports to fill the gap. But it was not done.

It is a matter of the fact that Sindh’s wheat crop comes early in the market and this year due to provincial food department’s failure in official procurement of the commodity the profiteer traders found an opportunity to make profits, so they purchased the crop at cheaper rates from Sindhi growers and sold the commodity in Punjab markets at higher margins. It is a matter of the fact that increase in wheat price has not benefit ted the growers in any case. Only traders have minted the money.

Interestingly, in Punjab there was an official ban on the movement of wheat from the province so with arrival of new crop this was locally consumed. But earlier supplies from Sindh to Punjab resulted in artificial shortage of wheat in Sindh, thus the price of 100 kg bag of wheat was increased to Rs. 4,400. The federal cabinet’s Economic Coordination Committee (ECC) on hue and cry had to ask the Pakistan Agriculture Storage and Services Corporation (PASSCO) to release 650,000 tonnes of wheat to the three provinces — Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP), Sindh and Balochistan. Sindh has reportedly received 100,000 tonnes from PASSCO so far.

The expert term the price hike because of full control of mafias on supply of essential food items like sugar, wheat flour, milk. The district administrations which are responsible for price control have, in practical terms, miserably failed to control the prices. For example, the Commissioner of Karachi has fixed price of a liter of milk at Rs. 94 but nowhere in the city it is available at the official rate. But it is being openly sold at the rate of Rs. 110 to 120/ liter.

“We have been raising our voice at the meetings on price control at Karachi Commissioner office on regular basis, but the administration seems helpless before these profiteers,” said Shakeel Baig, Chairman of Consumers Rights Protection Council of Pakistan.

Similar is the situation of prices of roti or naan. The government has asked the Tandoor owners to sell a 150 gram roti at the rate of Rs. 10, but it is not being sold at official rate anywhere in the city. “We have conducted our own research in the market and we have found that normally Tandoors sell a naan which is of weight of only 110 or 120 grams, which cost them around Rs. 8 after calculating all expenses, but they are not ready to reduce the prices,” he said. Tandoor owners however have their own complaints of increase in flour and gas prices.

In August the Prime Minister after public complaints had asked the gas companies to reduce gas rates for naan/roti makers so they are able to sell roti at reduced prices. But reports from different cities indicated that prices were not reduced anywhere.

Electricity, gas and petroleum prices have increased in Pakistan since early 2018, which has affected every section of the society. The Gross Domestic Product (GDP) growth rate has shrunk this year to 3.1 percent and the growth in large scale manufacturing was reported negative due to financial crisis.

The recent sky-rocketing prices of fruits and vegetables especially tomatoes due to failure of local crops has also made the lives of consumers miserable. Once the prices of a kilogram of tomato crossed Rs. 400, the government found no other solution but to allow imports of tomatoes from neighbouring Iran, which took some time to reach Pakistani markets.

Tomato import from eastern neighbor India is already banned due to technical reasons. Some three years back Pakistani quality managers found infectious germs in Indian tomatoes, so they put a ban, which is continued. However, local production of tomato is quite sufficient to suffice the country’s demand. Sindh is the first province, where crop ripens first followed by Southern Punjab and Balochistan. But this year tomotta tomato crop in Sindh was badly affected due to climate change effects. It was destroyed at its sowing stage due to heavy monsoon rains followed by untimely rains in September and October, which resulted in heavy losses to growers. The local farmers had to re-sow the tomato seeds after end of wet spell, but the crop was 40 percent less, a local farmer said. The local tomato crop from southern Sindh especially from Badin district has started arriving in Karachi’s vegetable market, however it is still insufficient to fulfill local demands.

With the arrival of Iranian supply the prices of tomatoes have substantially dropped to Rs. 200 a kilogram.